April 13, 1874 – Corrine, Utah Territory: Mob Removed Chinese Man Suspected of Murder from Prison and Lynched Him

Map showing location of Corrine, Utah

Narrative

In April 1874, in Corrine, Utah Territory, a vigilante mob forcefully removed a Chinese laborer from jail and hanged him. The Chinese man was accused of murdering a local man. The Fort Scott Daily Monitor reported that “while the officers were endeavoring to take the prisoner to Brigham City for safekeeping, the citizens en masse took him from the Marshal down to the railroad bridge one mile east of town and hung him from the trestle works” (April 15, 1874). We see again that a vigilante mob overrode the legal process even before the suspect was imprisoned. Vigilantes in the American West often claimed to be performing law enforcement in the absence of established, formal law and order. The Corrinne lynching undermines the validity of this pretext since, obviously, the suspect was in the custody of law officers and on his way to prison.

Related Newspaper Article(s)

Chinaman Lynched

The St. Louis Republican (St. Louis, Missouri)

April 15, 1874 (Page 1)

Citizens of Corinne, Utah, seize a jailed Chinese murder suspect (accused of killing Bornstein) from marshals and hang him from a railroad trestle while he is being moved for safekeeping, declaring vigilante justice served.

A Chinese Malefactor Lynched at Corinne

The San Francisco Examiner (San Francisco, California)

April 15, 1874 (Page 3)

A fuller Corinne dispatch credits Detective Thayer with proving a Chinese prisoner’s guilt in Bornstein’s murder; citizens then overpower officers, march the man to a railroad bridge, and lynch him, restoring “quiet” to the town.

Lynched

Fort Scott Daily Monitor (Fort Scott, Kansas)

April 15, 1874 (Page 1)

A Corinne, Utah mob seized a Chinese prisoner proven to have murdered merchant Bornstein and, despite officers escorting him to Brigham City, hanged him from a railroad trestle east of town on 14 Apr 1874; Detective Thayer and a Denver interpreter had traced the case.

A Chinaman Lynched

Marysville Daily Appeal (Marysville, California)

April 15, 1874 (Page 3)

Corinne, UT citizens seize a Chinese murder suspect being moved for safekeeping and hang him from a railroad trestle despite detectives’ efforts.