Two Drunken Miners Lynched a Chinese Man over an “Imaginary Crime”

Narrative

In early July 1873, two drunken miners near Silver Creek accused a Chinese man of stealing a ring they had lost and hanged him. The Ogden Junction said they carried out “summary vengeance” for an “imaginary crime,” while a later recollection in The Anaconda Standard remembered the killing as “A Chinaman Hung for Fun.” One of the attackers was later arrested, and retrospective accounts say Tim Collins eventually received a life sentence.

Related Newspaper Article(s)

Outrage in Montana

The Ogden Junction (Ogden, Utah)

August 2, 1873 (Page 4)

Two drunken miners in Montana lynched a Chinese man over a missing ring, later admitting the act to authorities. One was arrested and the other pursued.

A CHINAMAN HUNG FOR FUN

The Anaconda Standard (Anaconda, Montana)

March 1, 1891 (Page 5)

Old-timers in Butte reminisce about July 4, 1873, when Irish miners Dan Haffy and Tim Collins drunkenly lynched a passing Chinese man “for fun”; Collins later received a life sentence, claiming he served humanity.