Ah He Died After Boys Stoned Him

Narrative

On the evening of May 31, 1871, Ah He, the proprietor of a small cigar factory at Fourth and Freelon Streets in San Francisco, was attacked by a gang of boys and struck with stones. The San Francisco Call Bulletin reported that one of the stones hit him with such force that it “knocked him down and rendered him insensible,” and that he died the next morning at the City and County Hospital. Other papers emphasized that bystanders watched without intervening. For example, The Greenville Journal said that “dozens of people” witnessed the assault and “did not interfere until the murder was completed.” Later reports noted that even when two boys were held to bail, Chinese testimony about the incident had been excluded.

Related Newspaper Article(s)

A Chinaman Stoned to Death by Boys

The San Francisco Call Bulletin (San Francisco, California)

June 2, 1871 (Page 3)

Wednesday night, a Chinese cigar-maker named Ah He was stoned by a group of boys at Fourth and Freelon; Officer McSurley took him to the City and County Hospital, where he died at 6:15 a.m.; assailants unknown.

Death from Cause Unknown

The Sacramento Bee (Sacramento, California)

June 21, 1871 (Page 2)

Notes the New York Tribune’s praise that California newspapers condemned a coroner’s jury verdict of “Death from cause unknown” in the stoning death of a Chinese man in San Francisco, and asks how such a murder could go unpunished.

A Revival of Judicial Sensibility in San Francisco

The New York Times (New York, New York)

June 21, 1871 (Page 4)

Reports that after a Chinese man was stoned to death on May 31 in San Francisco, two boys were finally held to bail (one for murder, one for assault). Chinese testimony was offered but excluded; the Alta urges applying the Ku Klux bill.

Is California Relapsing into Barbarism

The Greenville Journal (Greenville, Ohio)

July 13, 1871 (Page 1)

Editorial notes a Chinese man was stoned to death in a San Francisco street while bystanders did not intervene, and reports a Mendocino mob ordered all Chinese to leave within ten days.